Okay, spank me, I’m a healthcare incrementalist — notwithstanding the broad dysfunction and obscene profit-chasing that characterizes U.S. healthcare.
I don’t think the U.S. is capable of a four-year transition to an entirely single-payer system. U.S. government capacity, weakened via underfunding for decades, is now deeply wounded by DOGE cuts and Trump administration corruption and incompetence. Our corrupt campaign finance system remains intact and would have to be dismantled before elected officials could take on healthcare industries all at once. Replacing employer contributions with taxes would very possibly cost Democrats their majority — fast. Plus, after watching the federal government corrupt itself under fascist grifter leadership for two years, I don’t want it controlling the whole healthcare system.
I have a lot of respect for Rosa De Lauro’s Medicare for America bill, the current iteration (originally introduced in 2018, recently re-introduced) of the Medicare-for-all-who-want it model. But on balance, I think it too is probably too big an all-at-once overhaul. For one thing, a lot of over-65 enrollees would pay more for Medicare than they do now -- though they would also get more. For another, I don’t know if the system could bear going to all-payer rates all at once — though I think we need to get there. (I examined various aspects of Medicare for America back in 2019.)
So that leaves me with kludge on kludge. I think this could be acceptable — if the patchwork a) offers genuinely affordable coverage to everyone and b) puts downward pressure on prices paid to providers — the main driver of healthcare unaffordability.
Here is a tentative and incomplete recipe:
Repeal the OBBA cuts to Medicaid — possibly replacing restoration of the admittedly crazy-quilt provider taxes and state-directed payments with a more rational federal payment boost.
Restore the enhanced premium tax credits in the ACA marketplace and repeal the vicious disqualification of various categories of lawfully present noncitizens.
Trade the uneven and accidental benefits offered by silver loading for a benchmark with higher actuarial value (e.g., a gold benchmark).
Introduce a strong public option into the marketplace, paying perhaps 120-130% Medicare rates, and require all providers that accept Medicare to accept it. The Medicare-X Choice Act, originally introduced in the first Trump administration by Senator Michael Bennet and reintroduced in 2025 (here is a House version introduced this year) creates such a strong public option, and would offer the plan in the small group market as well as the individual market. But in my view it does not open the door wide enough to those offered unaffordable assurance in the employer market, as discussed in the next item.
Radically lower the affordability threshold for employer sponsored insurance — that is, the premium as a percentage of income below which the employee is ineligible for marketplace subsidies. At present it’s about 10% of income for single-person coverage, which can have an actuarial value as low as 60%. A large and increasing percentage of low-income and middle-income employees are faced with options that make healthcare itself, if not nominal coverage, all but unaffordable. Lower the threshold to 8% of income for the whole household (whether single, dual or multiple) — and for coverage with at least 70% or maybe 80% AV.
Add an annual out-of-pocket cost cap to traditional Medicare, enabling it to compete on a more level field with Medicare Advantage. I think that’s more fundamental than providing dental/hearing/eye coverage in Medicare.
Overhaul Medicare Advantage payment, chiefly by eliminating incentives for upcoding, either by increasing the risk adjustment haircut — or, perhaps better, making MA risk adjustment zero-sum (as discussed with Richard Kronick here).
Leave 55-64 year-olds (or 50-64 year-olds) in the ACA marketplace, with its enhanced subsidies and strong public option. The latter should be simpler to implement than a separate “Medicare” benefit for this age group, with a separate risk pool.
Pass Senator Kim’s MediKids bill, entitling and presumptively enrolling all children and young adults up to age 26 in Medicaid (about half the nation’s kids are already enrolled in Medicaid).
Smooth the way for states to try to replicate Maryland’s all-payer payment model or otherwise regulate provider prices. Merrill Goozner has written extensively about such efforts (e.g., here). Yale scholars Zack Cooper and Christina Ramsay recently overviewed results from states that have moved in this direction. They’re pretty good.
Pick up the mantle of Biden-era FCT chair Lina Khan and DOJ antitrust head Jonathan Kanter and probe deep into anticompetitive behavior and profiteering by private equity in healthcare. Vigorously pursue antitrust enforcement against hospital systems, including vertical integration. Break up the conglomerates that the health insurance behemoths have assembled.
Okay, admittedly this program is pretty kludgy. And putting a real public option in the marketplace — with fixed payment rates and all-but-required provider participation is no easy lift. It’s a kind of Medicare for All or Medicare for All Who Want It incubator, but with a more limited initial enrollee base than either of those more sweeping approaches. But I think these measures taken together would reduce payment rates by degrees as well as expanding access to affordable care — and do it pretty quickly. If a strong public option took root and the marketplace — and was available to millions more currently offered coverage in the employer market — I think that would be a basis for moving further toward all-payer rates.
I will confess, too, that here I’ve written out attitudes and intuitions I was barely aware, and I would in fact be pleasantly surprised, if apprehensive, if something like the Medicare for America bill really gained momentum toward passage. I think this post was born of suspicion that bill proposing to extend “Medicare” eligibility to age 55 or 50 would create more inefficient kludge and confusion.
Photo is a public domain image from picryl.

No comments:
Post a Comment