Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Clinton to restore civil liberties?

Addled by fury at Hillary Clinton's pandering (gas tax holiday), saber rattling (obliterate Iran), and Rovian attacks on Obama (too numerous for parentheses), I took a cruise through recent speeches look for some ammo to prove a point (never mind).
On that quick skim I was at least reminded that Clinton is a Democrat. And in her April 15 speech to the Newspaper Association of America, I came across the most sustained and detailed promise I've seen from either Democratic candidate that Bush's assault on the Constitution would be rolled back.
Clinton started out by summarizing Bush Administration abuses. No surprise there.
The presidency is not royalty. Our Constitution is crafted carefully to prevent by election what our founders overthrew by revolution. The president is the one elected representative of the whole American people. Our president is balanced by the Congress, which speaks for regions and states, and by the courts, which defend the individual and other important rights against assaults on our liberties.

The president is the only constitutional office holder with the power to speak for all of us and with the potential to unify us in the service of our national interest.

Unfortunately, our current president does not seem to understand the basic character of the office he holds. Rather than faithfully execute the laws, he has rewritten them through signing statements, ignored them through secret legal opinions, undermined them by elevating ideology over facts. Rather than defending the Constitution, he has defied its principles and traditions. He has abused his power while failing to understand its purpose.

This administration's unbridled ambition to transform the executive into an imperial presidency in an attempt to strengthen the office has weakened our nation. It has corrupted and corroded our moral authority and brought our prestige and reputation to its lowest ebb. The president has failed to use the power of the presidency, the power he sought to inflate, to expand opportunity and make a real difference in people's lives.

She went on to express support for enhanced protection for journalists' sources and to promise "a presumption of openness and Freedom of Information Act requests and urge agencies to release information quickly if disclosure will do no harm." A tad ironic, given the Clinton Administration's long struggle to avoid disclosure and release of key documents. But secrecy is relative, and the Bush Administration has made Bill Clinton's look like an open book.

Most important, though, was a set of explicit promises to accept core Constitutional limits on Presidential power:

...because government abuse is checked by the separation of powers, I will restore respect for our co-equal branches of government. I’ll start by limiting the excessive executive powers this president has accumulated, like the unilateral power to wiretap, or detain try people, even American citizens. I will work with Congress again as a partner to solve problems. I’ll end the use of signing statements to rewrite the laws that Congress has passed. I’ll shut down Guantanamo, disavow torture and restore the right of Habeas Corpus.

I will end the practice of using executive privilege as a shield against the public’s right to know and congress’ duty to oversee the president.

Finally I will make crystal clear that the president and the executive branch will comply with the laws of our nation. My Department of Justice will interpret those laws fairly accurately honestly and publically. We’ll release Justice Department interpretations so that you know exactly what our understanding is and how laws are being executed. The President is not above the law in our system of government and we need to make that absolutely clear starting next year. These changes both represent and drive the transformation I believe is needed in our government starting on day one of my administration. I do not believe that power is an end in itself but a means. A means limited in scope of serving the interest and protecting the safety of our nation, while creating opportunity for our people.
Do I believe that Clinton would de-imperialize the Presidency? Not entirely. After this campaign, I don't take anything she says at face value. Nevertheless, here is a series of explicit promises to which she can be held accountable. I’ll end the use of signing statements to rewrite the laws that Congress has passed. I’ll shut down Guantanamo, disavow torture and restore the right of Habeas Corpus.

There's always wiggle room for the shameless, as we've learned from George "We Do Not Torture" Bush. But credit where credit is due - Clinton said what needed to be said here.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Share